Free shipping from 2 products

United KingdomEUR €
United KingdomEUR €
United Kingdom GBP £
Is Jimmy Joy or Whole Supp Better?

Is Jimmy Joy or Whole Supp Better?

Is Jimmy Joy or Whole Supp Better?

With so many meal replacement shake brands available in the market, it can be difficult to know which one is right for you.

Meal replacement powders have become a popular choice for busy individuals looking for a convenient, quick, and easy way to get their daily nutrition. 

By the end of this blog, you'll have all the information you need to make an informed decision on which one best suits your dietary needs and priorities.

Here are five reasons why people are choosing Whole Supp over Jimmy Joy Plenny Shakes:

1. Better ingredients for performance

Jimmy Joy Plenny Shakes V3.0, ingredients include:

Oat flour, Soy flour, Sunflower oil, Rice flour, Soy protein isolate, Inulin, Ground golden flax seeds, Vitamin and mineral mix, Sweetener: sucralose, Bacillus Coagulans

In contrast, here’s what you’ll find in Whole Supp:

Sustainably sourced red sea Algae, Organic Cherries, Broccoli, Beetroot Juice, Spinach, Pea Portion, Rice Portion, Gluten-Free Ground Oats, Sunflower, flaxseed, coconut, MTC Oils, 100% Vanilla Bean or Cacao Powder, Sucralose.

Jimmy Joy Plenny Shakes uses both soy flour and soy protein isolate. It is important to point out some concerns about the use of soy protein:

  • Soy protein contains phytoestrogens, which are plant compounds that can mimic the effects of estrogen in the body. A recent research review concluded that “Consumers should be aware that soy contains endocrine disrupting compounds and make dietary choices accordingly. For a typical consumer, alarm over soy products is likely unnecessary but…Women who are pregnant, nursing, or attempting to become pregnant should use soy foods with caution." - The pros and cons of phytoestrogens, Front Neuroendocrinol
  • Some people may experience digestive issues such as bloating and gas when consuming soy protein.

This is worth keeping in mind when choosing a meal shake.

2. Higher and complete protein profile for an active lifestyle

One of the primary differences between Whole Supp and Jimmy Joy is the protein content. 

Whole Supp provides 31g of protein per serving, whereas Jimmy Joy provides 25g of protein per serving.  

Whole Supp's higher protein content may make it a more suitable option for individuals who engage in regular exercise or have increased protein requirements due to age, injury, or illness.  

Whole Supp's super premium protein comes from a blend of pea, and brown rice protein, which equate to a complete protein profile, containing all essential amino acids necessary for protein synthesis in the body.  In contrast, Jimmy Joy's protein source comes primarily from soy based ingredients which has a lower composition of the essential amino acids including leucine which are important for muscle health and function. 

Soy is also a complete protein but may not be suitable for individuals soy allergies, soy sensitivities due to health reasons or digestive intolerances as mentioned earlier.

What's in Whole Supp

3. Lower sugar content

Whole Supp stands out as a superior brand not only due to its protein content but also for its low sugar content.  

Whole Supp contains 51% less sugar than Jimmy Joy at 1.8g of sugar per serving, while Jimmy Joy contains 3.5g of sugar per serving. 

This may be an important consideration for individuals who are trying to reduce their sugar intake or who are following a low-carbohydrate diet.

4. Some customer reviews say Jimmy Joy isn't easy on the stomach

Whole Supp takes gut health seriously.

Our formulation is allergen free as standard, whereas some of Jimmy Joy's products contain gluten and soy which may pose concern for individuals with sensitivities or intolerances. 

Not only does Whole Supp contain prebiotics to aid digestion, our formulation also contains additional superfoods such as organic cherries, broccoli, spinach, beetroot, red sea algae to name a few, which provide additional nutrients and antioxidants. These superfoods provide amazing support for a healthy gut too. 

Jimmy Joy Plenny Shakes, on the other hand, does not offer these additional components. This may be an important consideration for individuals who are looking for a more nutrient-dense meal replacement powder that is easy on the stomach.

5. A more sustainable choice

When it comes to choosing between Whole Supp and Jimmy Joy, packaging can also be a significant factor to consider.

While both brands offer recyclable packaging, Whole Supp takes sustainability a step further with their home compostable and 90% recycled pouches. 

This eco-friendly option can be a crucial factor for individuals who prioritize reducing their environmental impact and want to make a sustainable choice. In contrast, Jimmy Joy's recyclable packaging may still contribute to waste and take longer to decompose.

What about price?

Lastly, let’s talk about the pricing. Whole Supp costs €2.33 per serving (single purchase, not subscription), whereas Jimmy Joy's Plenny Shakes 3.0 costs €1.79 per serving (single purchase, not subscription).

While Whole Supp is more expensive compared to Jimmy Joy it is important to note your “bang for your buck”.

With Whole Supp you are getting numerous superfoods, powerful antioxidants and a more complete, low sugar formulation to support optimal wellness and performance.

Final Verdict: 

In conclusion, our product comparison between Whole Supp and Jimmy Joy has revealed some significant differences that may be important considerations for individuals seeking a meal replacement powder. 

Whole Supp's higher protein content, superfoods and low-sugar content make it a better choice for those who prioritize an active busy lifestyle. The composition of Whole Supp ensures you get sustainable energy without an energy crash. 

The slightly higher price for Whole Supp can is justified by the additional benefits it offers due to the better proteins and superfoods included. 

Moreover, Whole Supp's gluten-free and nutrient-dense composition, coupled with its eco-friendly and sustainable packaging, make it a more well-rounded option.

Curious to try Whole Supp? Get the Starter Pack at 40% Off: Includes a Choclate or Vanilla Bag (15 portions), a Shaker and Free Shipping!

Apr 28, 2023• Posted by Darren O’Reilly

Further reading


Follow for all things wholesome


for all things wholesome